Argh, how did I miss the start of this? I expected to be pounded by me frog... sorry dude >_<

(tipping we don't need reasons for votes anymore... if I'm wrong, someone yell at me and i'll post again)

4 - Psycho Penguin
29 - SinirothX (this one's a close call)
13 - Kao Megura
45 - Aaron Baker
5 - Split Infinity
37 - EOrizzonte
53 - Apathetic Aardvark
44 - shoecream

---
Old loves, they die hard... Old lies, they die harder
o.O Push button to turn on. Play with button to drive wild.

(tipping we don't need reasons for votes anymore... if I'm wrong, someone yell at me and i'll post again)

You don't, so no worries. :D

---
Devin Morgan | CRP #3579
NES Completion Project: http://web.njit.edu/~dbm7/

All abstains are due to me never having read their work.

4 - Psycho Penguin
vs.
61 - JCulbert

JCulbert gets cool points for having the lowest contributor page ID of all writers in this contest, but PP's superior amount of content and diversity edge out.

Abstain

Abstain

20 - JChamberlin
vs.
45 - Aaron Baker

Akin to reasons stated before, Aaron Baker is a fairly unknown writer, but he's still pretty good in many areas.

Abstain

Abstain

12 - kylohk
vs.
53 - Apathetic Aardvark

This was a somewhat hard choice to make, and there weren't any guide comparisons I could actually make. However, kylohk's guides either have a sense of bloatedness (see: Tales of Symphonia), or otherwise lack lots of line breaks (see: Resident Evil). Other than that, AA's guides seem to have a cleaner format, although not by much.

21 - DJ Tigresa
vs.
44 - shoecream

This wasn't really a hard matchup. Any points I have against DJ Tigresa have already been mentioned, but he wins by the sheer fact that shoecream hardly has any work that helps out the casual gamer (ie. that 3693KB Baldur's Gate II Monster Encyclopaedia might be useful to a dedicated player, but a casual player. Nope)

4 - Psycho Penguin
36 - Red Scarlet
13 - Kao Megura
20 - JChamberlin
60 - Minesweeper
37 - EOrizzonte
53 - Apathetic Aardvark
21 - DJ Tigresa

---
Y.T.W.S.R.