CNET Games & Entertainment GameSpot | GameFAQs | MP3.com | TV.com
Welcome, Crazyreyn

 
FAQ Contributors - General
Crazyreyn (34) | Board List | Topic List

This Topic has been marked closed. No additional messages may be posted.

Eighth Prolific FAQers Tourney - Division 1, Round 1
From: Devin Morgan | Posted: 7/5/2005 8:38:40 PM | Message Detail
Well it's been over a year since the last tourney, but after much anticipation it is now underway. Everyone here should know how these work by now, vote for the better author in each set of matches based on quality of work. There is a rule set as always, posted on the bracket itself, so check that out if you wish (it's all common sense really but some of it needs to be spelled out for the less intelligent users of the board). Anyway, here's the bracket (which also has CRP links to all authors in this tourney, for reference), and the first division of matches, good luck!

http://web.njit.edu/~dbm7/pbracket8.htm

1 - A I e x
vs.
64 - Adrenaline SL

32 - TestaALT
vs.
33 - CWall

16 - me frog
vs.
49 - Karpah

17 - Joni Philips
vs.
48 - Yami Shuryou

8 - DSimpson
vs.
57 - antseezee

25 - EChang
vs.
40 - CMoriarty

9 - BSulpher
vs.
56 - strawhat

24 - Mysticcat
vs.
41 - marshmallow

---
Devin Morgan | CRP #3579
NES Completion Project: http://web.njit.edu/~dbm7/
From: CVXFREAK | Posted: 7/5/2005 8:40:53 PM | Message Detail
I really have a lot of catching up to do with the FAQ Board. >>

64 - Adrenaline SL
32 - TestaALT
49 - Karpah
17 - Joni Philips
8 - DSimpson
40 - CMoriarty
9 - BSulpher
24 - Mysticcat

A lot of close matches here, it was hard to choose.
---
CVXFREAK: "I'll sell you a copy of RE4 for $2."
Vyers: "Can't afford it."
From: Dark Vortex | Posted: 7/5/2005 8:46:14 PM | Message Detail
[This message was deleted at the request of the original poster]
From: Dark Vortex | Posted: 7/5/2005 8:46:39 PM | Message Detail
1 - Adrenaline SL

32 - TestaALT

49 - Karpah

17 - Joni Philips

8 - DSimpson

25 - EChang

9 - BSulpher

24 - Mysticcat
---
~ L.F.H. ~ | Y.T.W.S.R.
The Light At Board #19313
From: Kirby021591 | Posted: 7/5/2005 8:53:51 PM | Message Detail
64 - Adrenaline SL

33 - CWall

16 - me frog

17 - Joni Philips

8 - DSimpson

40 - CMoriarty

9 - BSulpher

41 - marshmallow

We've got some close matches this time around. Indeed, this was well put together. Thanks for hosting, Devin.
---
See ya later.
From: SayainPrince | Posted: 7/5/2005 9:10:55 PM | Message Detail
1 - A I e x
32 - TestaALT
16 - me frog
17 - Joni Philips
57 - antseezee
40 - CMoriarty
9 - BSulpher
24 - Mysticcat

---
"You found a ppv without HHH! Now, can you find Waldo?" - Me
"I found 172 waldos in HHH's nose. Thats where they all hide." - PsychoPenguin
From: BostonFuse51 | Posted: 7/5/2005 9:13:00 PM | Message Detail
1 - A I e x
33 - CWall
16 - me frog (I love you man, but where are you...)
17 - Joni Philips
57 - antseezee
25 - EChang
56 - strawhat
41 - marshmallow

---
The Boston Red Sox 43-30
Next Game: Phills
From: strawhat | Posted: 7/5/2005 9:17:15 PM | Message Detail
1 - A I e x
vs.
64 - Adrenaline SL

32 - TestaALT
vs.
33 - CWall

16 - me frog
vs.
49 - Karpah

17 - Joni Philips
vs.
48 - Yami Shuryou

8 - DSimpson
vs.
57 - antseezee

25 - EChang
vs.
40 - CMoriarty

24 - Mysticcat
vs.
41 - marshmallow
---
Number of official GameFAQs Knick fans: 10
Flag me down if you're a fan!
From: CFlames55117 | Posted: 7/5/2005 9:19:22 PM | Message Detail
1 - A I e x
32 - TestaALT
49 - Karpah
17 - Joni Philips
8 - DSimpson
25 - EChang
9 - BSulpher
41 - marshmallow
---
Currently Playing:ESPN College Hoops 2k5
From: Joni Philips | Posted: 7/5/2005 9:22:46 PM | Message Detail
1 - A I e x (He is a hard worker, his work is clear and easy to understand, makes sure his work is fully finished when submitting and he is more straight forward imho, Adrenaline's writing is better but A l e x's writing style will help the gamers faster. Just my feeling after reading about 5 guides of each of them on games I know)

33 - CWall

49 - Karpah (me frog's text doesn't flow right, uses a lot of too short sentences, that is not the main reason I voted against him but it is just a tip for if he reads this)

Abstain, can't vote in this one.

57 - antseezee

40 - CMoriarty

9 - BSulpher

41 - marshmallow (Mysticcat, there is a small mistake in the CRP number at the bracket page, it is supposed to be 477, not 447)
---
Goku- Look Vegeta! People popcorn!
Vegeta- Ah! What is he on?!
From: A I e x | Posted: 7/5/2005 9:23:59 PM | Message Detail
[This message was deleted at the request of the original poster]
From: Merca | Posted: 7/5/2005 9:25:21 PM | Message Detail
64 - Adrenaline SL
32 - TestaALT
49 - Karpah
17 - Joni Philips
8 - DSimpson
40 - CMoriarty
9 - BSulpher
24 - Mysticcat

---
Y.T.W.S.R.
From: Devin Morgan | Posted: 7/5/2005 9:26:20 PM | Message Detail
Alex, that's what the point of providing everyone's CRP is, so you can check out everyone's work you haven't already and make a judgement on that. I see it pointless to even vote if you're just going to abstain the majority of matchups. :P

---
Devin Morgan | CRP #3579
NES Completion Project: http://web.njit.edu/~dbm7/
From: Parasite Eve II | Posted: 7/5/2005 9:38:16 PM | Message Detail
64 - Adrenaline SL
32 - TestaALT
49 - Karpah
48 - Yami Shuryou
57 - antseezee
40 - CMoriarty
9 - BSulpher
41 - marshmallow

Tough matchups.
---
- Parasite Eve II -
From: CNICK | Posted: 7/5/2005 9:39:13 PM | Message Detail
64 - Adrenaline SL
32 - TestaALT
49 - Karpah
48 - Yami Shuryou
8 - DSimpson
40 - CMoriarty
9 - BSulpher
41 - marshmallow
From: A I e x | Posted: 7/5/2005 9:44:21 PM | Message Detail
Ok fine, but if I can put in single vote, for EChang, that's all that matters to me ;)
---
Games - http://users.ign.com/collection/A_I_e_x?objType=1
Guides - http://www.gamefaqs.com/features/recognition/45802.html
From: winnie the poop | Posted: 7/5/2005 9:45:58 PM | Message Detail
64 - Adrenaline SL

33 - CWall

49 - Karpah

ABSTAIN

57 - antseezee

40 - CMoriarty

9 - BSulpher

41 - marshmallow
---
What is past is prologue.
From: Meowthnum1 | Posted: 7/5/2005 9:52:31 PM | Message Detail
1 - A I e x
32 - TestaALT
16 - me frog
17 - Joni Philips
8 - DSimpson
40 - CMoriarty
9 - BSulpher
41 - marshmallow

Man, I'm totally going out in the first round.

THANKS A LOT, DEV.

(just kidding)
---
Randomize()
"Women are like Voltron - the more you can hookup, the better it gets." | Y.T.S.W.R
From: Lu4R | Posted: 7/5/2005 10:22:24 PM | Message Detail
1 - A I e x

33 - CWall

49 - Karpah

17 - Joni Philips

8 - DSimpson

25 - EChang

56 - strawhat

41 - marshmallow
From: make me dance | Posted: 7/5/2005 11:21:39 PM | Message Detail
64 - Adrenaline SL
33 - CWall
49 - Karpah
48 - Yami Shuryou
57 - antseezee
40 - CMoriarty
9 - BSulpher
24 - Mysticcat
---
omg lololol
From: Da Hui | Posted: 7/5/2005 11:34:22 PM | Message Detail
64 - Adrenaline SL
32 - TestaALT
16 - me frog
48 - Yami Shuryou
8 - DSimpson
25 - EChang
9 - BSulpher
41 - marshmallow
---
Don't **** with Da Hui
From: Automatic_Flush | Posted: 7/6/2005 12:17:37 AM | Message Detail
1 - A I e x

33 - CWall

16 - me frog

17 - Joni Philips

57 - antseezee

40 - CMoriarty

9 - BSulpher

41 - marshmallow
From: namod65 | Posted: 7/6/2005 12:23:03 AM | Message Detail
64 - Adrenaline SL

33 - CWall

16 - me frog

17 - Joni Philips

57 - antseezee

40 - CMoriarty

9 - BSulpher

41 - marshmallow
---
namod65 | Total FAQs: 10 | KB: 1071 | (Non-Prolific)
Current project: Lord of the Rings: The Third Age | Next project: Undecided
From: Crazyreyn | Posted: 7/6/2005 12:44:15 AM | Message Detail
Agreed, good matchups Dev, most of these had me scratching my head for about 5 minutes.

1 - A I e x (A REALLY hard one to decide. At first I thought Adrenaline easily, as I remember some of Alex's work being a little sloppy, but on another look Adrenaline isn't 100% consistent. Format with both is a bit off IMO, but Alex prevails. Looking at simular FAQs, Alex has a very poor MGS FAQ IMO while Adrenaline has a corker in MGS2; RPGs are about the same and GTA FAQs Alex does better. For FAQ diversity and amount Alex gets points too. To conclude Alex just skins through here, barely - he needs to take care and write better on some of his FAQs like he does on others.)

32 - TestaALT (I feel he puts in the extra bit of detail that really helps; more diverse too)

16 - me frog (Bec's RPG FAQs ie. the FF's are extremely filler tastic, in that she comments on the story. A lot. Big minus points in my book. me frog is better but some FAQs like Mario Kart DD!! is a bit fillerish but overall he's more to the point and is more diverse. me frog is the clear winnar)

48 - Yami Shuryou (overall better, content and format wise; nothing else to add really)

8 - DSimpson (antseezee is really good but Dan has done some amazing stuff in Balders and KOTOR2, including great formatting and ASCII maps. antseezee's format is a bit weak and not as diverse FAQ wise as Dan either).

40 - CMoriarty (more diverse, far better format, schweet ASCII diagrams, and EChang seems to be made up for indepth FAQs from his main walkthroughs. However Colin's Mario Sunshine is one big ball of filler evil)

9 - BSulpher (strawhat was unlucky here, Sulpher is gonna walk straight through 95% of the people in this contest. For it's worth, strawhat has the nicer format overall though)

41 - marshmallow (nicer content and format. Mysticcat is good, but her format is horrid and she has recycled her Resi FAQs across multiple formats, which is nasty. She does have some awesome ASCII map skillz and her Koudelka FAQ is rather good though)
---
Reyn | Y.T.W.S.R. | FAQs: 43
The Official FCB Profiles and History - http://homepages.tesco.net/vicky.reynolds1
From: brian sulpher | Posted: 7/6/2005 12:59:18 AM | Message Detail
64 - Adrenaline SL (As good as Alex is, he is no Adrenaline)

Neither (Both authors kick ass, I am unable to vote here).

49 - Karpah (A close one, but Bec's ability to FAQ DKC3 so nicely gets her the nod).

48 - Yami Shuryou (Although I rather like Joni, I find Spacefighter to be slightly ahead here).

Neither (I do not find one author superior or inferior to the other).

40 - CMoriarty (I loved Colin's work back in the day, but it has aged horribly. Still, he gets my vote over EChang's offerings... barely).

Abstain

24 - Mysticcat (Although Mystic cat has some serious issues in her formatting and word use, Marshmallow does as well. This means she gets the nod as english is not her first language).

---
55 FAQs for games never covered at www.GameFAQs.com.
Now with a NES FAQ for each letter of the alphabet!
From: Blueberry Buttface | Posted: 7/6/2005 1:27:24 AM | Message Detail
64 - Adrenaline SL

33 - CWall

49 - Karpah

48 - Yami Shuryou

57 - antseezee

40 - CMoriarty

9 - BSulpher

41 - marshmallow
---
_,.,:;~'`'{.,::[\\=THE ONLY SB=//]::,.}'`'~;:,.,_
`'`':;-;,._:;`'`';:_.;~ArkticNight~;._:;'`'`;:_.,;-;:'`'`
From: Gbness | Posted: 7/6/2005 1:40:19 AM | Message Detail
1 - A I e x
vs.
64 - Adrenaline SL

Extremely difficult match up, but it edges out very, very slightly towards Adrenaline. They're both great writers and great workers, but Adrenaline is perhaps my favorite writer on the entire site. Her guides are hilarious to read, and worth reading just for the enjoyment, not only if you need help for a game. Her formats are awesome, too... I'm wondering just how she did some of those. A I e x is an awesome writer too, and I've used several of his guides, but there's pretty much no one I'd vote for over Adrenaline SL.

32 - TestaALT
vs.
33 - CWall

TestaALT is another writer in which I enjoy reading, and his FFIX guide, while it pales in comparison to mine *ahem* is awesome stuff all the same. CWall's a great writer too, although I obviously can't read some of his stuff, it being in Swedish.

16 - me frog
vs.
49 - Karpah

Both have a few weaknesses in writing, but I find me frog's to be more fatal. Some of his guides just don't flow quite as well as Bec's, and while both are enjoyable to read, I prefer Karpah's slightly. That's not to mention me frog's guides are full of spelling mistakes occasionally. That being said, they're both great writers all the same, and me frog is a very hard worker.

17 - Joni Philips
vs.
48 - Yami Shuryou

8 - DSimpson
vs.
57 - antseezee

25 - EChang
vs.
40 - CMoriarty

EChang has some very overall impressive RPG work up... plus, CMoriarty was somewhat overrated in his time, in my opinion... some of his guides don't have great flow, I don't like his format much, and some of his paragraphs are far too long, as for what my memory can serve.

9 - BSulpher
vs.
56 - strawhat

strawhat is an entertaining writer to read, and VERY underrated in my book... but I still have to give props to Brian Blues here, da master of da NES and all dat yo yo yo.

24 - Mysticcat
vs.
41 - marshmallow

Some of Mysticcat's stuff, namely Fatal Frame II and Legend of Dragoon is awesome... marshmallow's not bad, but was fairly overrated in his time.
---
Come to Space Harrier, board 571756.
~ #5 ~
From: GhostOfLegault | Posted: 7/6/2005 2:25:55 AM | Message Detail
64 - Adrenaline SL

32 - TestaALT

16 - me frog

48 - Yami Shuryou

8 - DSimpson

40 - CMoriarty

56 - strawhat

41 - marshmallow

---
#1 Peep
"I will give you a show that you have never, ever seen before. Why? Because I can." - HBK
From: nintendomaster14 | Posted: 7/6/2005 3:21:05 AM | Message Detail
1 - A I e x
32 - TestaALT
16 - me frog
48 - Yami Shuryou
57 - antseezee
40 - CMoriarty
56 - strawhat
41 - marshmallow

---
nm14 - FAQ writer for GameFAQs
From: SubSane | Posted: 7/6/2005 4:18:08 AM | Message Detail
Mysticcat's CRP is 10477.

1 - A I e x (More straight forward with his writing and he's just got tons more stuff)

32 - TestaALT (Dig the comprehensive walkthrough goodness)

16 - me frog (Liked both writers' structure and style, so I had to go with volume)

48 - Yami Shuryou (Once again some good writing, but I preferred the layout/structure)

57 - antseezee (I'm a DSimpson fan, but antseezee's got good writing and work up the wazoo)

40 - CMoriarty (Rocks it with good formatting and writing)

9 - BSulpher (Slightly better formatting and coverage for older games)

41 - marshmallow (The writing seems to be more clear in these FAQs than in the others)

---
Street toughs took my armoire?
::Elite Rogue:: {//=|RDoN|=\\}
From: TestaALT | Posted: 7/6/2005 5:54:12 AM | Message Detail
64 - Adrenaline SL
Abstain
16 - me frog
48 - Yami Shuryou
57 - antseezee
40 - CMoriarty
9 - BSulpher
24 - Mysticcat
From: Devin Morgan | Posted: 7/6/2005 7:12:04 AM | Message Detail
64 - Adrenaline SL
32 - TestaALT
16 - me frog
48 - Yami Shuryou
8 - DSimpson
40 - CMoriarty
9 - BSulpher
24 - Mysticcat

---
Devin Morgan | CRP #3579
NES Completion Project: http://web.njit.edu/~dbm7/
From: FFMrebirth | Posted: 7/6/2005 7:12:34 AM | Message Detail
1 - A I e x
32 - TestaALT
16 - me frog
17 - Joni Philips
8 - DSimpson
40 - CMoriarty
56 - strawhat
41 - marshmallow (Mysticcats read like this: DEN U GO 2 STORE BUY SWORD ATTACK GREEN ODD MONSTER UGLY TO TOWN AGAIN)
From: Astro Blade | Posted: 7/6/2005 12:41:30 PM | Message Detail
64 - Adrenaline SL
32 - TestaALT
16 - me frog
48 - Yami Shuryou
8 - DSimpson
40 - CMoriarty
9 - BSulpher
41 - marshmallow
---
Mattman
From: arminjewell | Posted: 7/6/2005 4:16:54 PM | Message Detail
64 - Adrenaline SL
33 - CWall
49 - Karpah
17 - Joni Philips
8 - DSimpson
40 - CMoriarty
9 - BSulpher
24 - Mysticcat
---
RPG Elite (298) Nemesis : little_jewell
| A.K.A | FAQs: 11 (2808 KB) | Reviews: 5 (20 KB) | Codes: 152
From: Swiftshark | Posted: 7/6/2005 5:23:08 PM | Message Detail
64 - Adrenaline SL
33 - CWall
49 - Karpah
48 - Yami Shuryou
8 - DSimpson
40 - CMoriarty
9 - BSulpher
41 - marshmallow
---
"Bold courage never succumbed to facile intimidation."
From: bluberry | Posted: 7/6/2005 9:50:53 PM | Message Detail
A I e x, TestaALT, Karpah, Yami Shuryou, DSimpson, CMoriarty, BSulpher, marshmallow
---
"I'd have [a parrot] say things like 'RWARK No one has ass freckles, use a condom!'" - Dave Attell
From: SineNomine | Posted: 7/6/2005 9:52:33 PM | Message Detail
64 - Adrenaline SL
33 - CWall
49 - Karpah
48 - Yami Shuryou
57 - antseezee
25 - EChang
9 - BSulpher
41 - marshmallow
From: Space Medafighter X | Posted: 7/6/2005 10:01:03 PM | Message Detail
1 - A I e x

32 - TestaALT

49 - Karpah

Abstain

57 - antseezee

40 - CMoriarty

9 - BSulpher

41 - marshmallow
---
We are the ones who bare their fangs at God himself...
We are...Assassins of the Night...Board 10502....
From: Devin Morgan | Posted: 7/6/2005 10:01:25 PM | Message Detail
No more votes n ow.
---
Devin Morgan | CRP #3579
NES Completion Project: http://web.njit.edu/~dbm7/
From: muddy_lee | Posted: 7/6/2005 10:03:41 PM | Message Detail
I'm too late...
---
Won't change until I get a girlfriend. Started 6/30/05